I bought the BSH intake after considering many other makes. Ultimately it came down to the single piece tube, and optional DV relocation port that's available for future modifications. I also really like being able to see my filter without disassembling any components. Helps me with maintenance.
I've had the Intake for about 6000KM and am thoroughly pleased with the sound, and pull that my GTI receives above 4000RPM. It really cleaned up the engine bay, and gave me more room to see and work. To be fair and unbiased, I wish the airbox where the filter sits had one more bolt to help keep it in place, but that's my only complaint.